A christmas carol differences from book to adaptations november 27, 2016 4 comments in 80s and 90s central, blogs by richb i love a christmas carol, its a great novel and has made for some fantastic adaptations on stage and screen. The full title of charles dickens most famous work is technically a christmas carol in prose, being a ghoststory of christmas. The best film adaptations of charles dickens a christmas. A christmas carol, the popular 1843 novella by charles dickens 18121870, is one of the british authors bestknown works. The technology has caught up a bit, making the characters. Top 10 greatest a christmas carol adaptations youtube. Bean, rowan atkinson played edmund blackadder, or actually generations of edmund blackadders whose misfortunes span. Binge all of the a christmas carol adaptations the. The new york times has called this the best adaptation of a christmas carol ever made, and its hard to disagree. A new christmas carol explores the roots of scrooges. The muppet christmas carol 1992 something about a christmas carol is so fitting with music and thusly, musicals. It set me wondering about all the different film adaptations there must have been over the years, and so i decided to begin researching the various celluloid incarnations of ebenezer scrooge by compiling a list of the many adaptations of a christmas carol and, having. Singing is described in the novella and even in nonmusical adaptations, carollers are regularly seen, just before they are shoed away by scrooge like street rats. This novella was published on december 19, 1843, and the first edition run of 6000 copies were sold out by christmas eve of that year.
A christmas carol captured the zeitgeist of the midvictorian revival of the christmas holiday. Okay, granted, this is technically not a direct adaptation of a christmas carol, rather a bill murray comedy which happens to follow a similar plot. What better way to celebrate than with charles dickens classic book a christmas carol. When for instance scrooge asks his nephews wife for forgiveness for being a pig headed old fool it never fails to have me reaching for the nearest. I am sure charles dickens would be more than pleased with the film adaptation of a christmas carol. Not so in eighties classic scrooged, where bill murray goes full bastard with his character frank cross subtle, an angry tv network president and modernday ebenezer who is broadcasting a. Here are the top 10 best adaptations of a christmas carol. Some of the best moments from other adaptations of a christmas carol come while watching scrooge act like a lighthearted boy once more, despite his advanced age and notorious reputation as a cruel. And then, as a gift to dickens, i would have to compile a list of movie and tv adaptations of charles dickenss awesome booka christmas caroland id want those adaptations to. The five best film adaptations of a christmas carol. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. A christmas carol tells the story of ebenezer scrooge, an old miser who is visited by the ghost of his former business partner jacob marley and the ghosts of. The 7 best nontraditional christmas carol adaptations.
More scholarly than paul sammons, a christmas carol carol book, this tome gives some outstanding history on the various a christmas carol adaptations on film, television, and precinema. The best book on a christmas carol and its adaptations. Adaptations of a christmas carol fall into three rough categories. In 1935, seymour hicks reprised the part he had made his own in thousands of stage versions, plus the 19 film adaptation, and played the title role in this, the first talking version of the dickens classic. From a muppet christmas carol to the mickey mouse version and more, steve gustafson take a look at the best adaptations of a christmas carol. A christmas carol must bewith the exception of the nativity narratives in matthew and lukethe best known christmas story in the world. While the internet is full of best and worst lists, were bringing you the definitive a christmas carol adaptations specially for book nerds. Released in 1951, it is available from vci home video.
Interesting facts about dickenss a christmas carol. However, if you start to get bored by it, then we have the perfect alternative adaptations for you. But like any cultural touchstone, a christmas carol adaptations range from the delightful to the derivative. We delve back into more than a century of a christmas carol movies to find the best and worst adaptations of dickens festive tale.
A christmas carol film adaptations best and worst movie. The first of these is a straight adaptation, or interpretation of the story of the sake of the story, with an attempt to keep as close to the dickens text as is possible. Reginald own stars as scrooge, with gene and kathleen lockhart as the cratchits. The many adaptations of charles dickens a christmas carol ranked from worst to best, from a 1901 silent film to the 2009 computergenerated feature. A critical examination of dickenss story and its productions on screen and television new ed by fred guida isbn. I was hoping for some other good recommendations for other versions of the story. The good, the bad and the ugly video by sammy perlmutter. Just about every one of them deserves to be boiled with its own pudding and buried with a. So the figure itself fluctuated in its distinctness adaptations of a christmas carol fall into three rough categories.
A critical examination of dickenss story and its productions on screen and television 276. If you are like me, a christmas carol, which is based on the book by charles dickens, must be watched at least once in the lead up to christmas. A christmas carol has never been out of print and has been translated into several languages. Alastair sim is absolutely perfect as ebenezer scrooge, nailing each aspect of the character as he evolves from bitter and angry to frightened and regretful and finally renewed and joyful. Scott film from 1984, but i had no idea there were so many different adaptations of this novel. Yes, some are the sort of story you gather with family to enjoy every year, but some are.
A christmas caroldifferences from book to adaptations. Its charles dickenss novella classic a christmas carolwe all read it in grade school and have watched it come to life again and again on screens big and small. The second is the use of the story as a medium through which to make an often unrelated point. Since the release of dickens a christmas carol, the book has received many adaptations, turning into an opera, a ballet, a broadway musical and of course tv specials. If you enjoy dickens, a christmas carol or just christmas youll love whats to learn from author guida. Here, we share the best christmas carol adaptations.
The surprising story behind dickenss a christmas carol charles dickenss classic christmas tale a christmas carol was published over 170 years ago, in 1843. I tried ranking a christmas carol adaptations and it. I have watched about a dozen adaptations of a christmas carol in the last week, and let me tell you. A truly remarkable film that never fails to delight me. Too many christmas carol adaptations gloss over the fact that ebenezer scrooge is an absolute dickenshead, throwing in a few halfhearted humbugs and a couple of mean stares before calling the job done. It is the story of ebenezer scrooge, a greedy miser who hates christmas, but is transformed into a caring, kindly person through the visitations of four ghosts.
Since its publication in 1843, a christmas carol has been cemented as a classic book, as well as a seminal piece of the holiday zeitgeist. Dickens had acknowledged the influence of the modern western observance of christmas and later inspired several aspects of christmas, including family gatherings, seasonal food and drink, dancing, games and a festive generosity. One of the most highly regarded versions of a christmas carol stars ahstair sims as scrooge, directed by brian desmond hurst. For this list, were looking at the best tv and movies based on the famous 1843 novel by charles dickens. As fred guida points out in this book, however, people may know the story more from the many film and tv versions that have been produced since 1901 than from dickenss novel, so a knowledge of these adaptations is necessary in discussing the storys appeal. In what is the highestbudgeted christmas carol adaptation to date and will be for some time, robert zemeckis returns to the performance capture technology that was so panned by critics in his the polar express. My favorite version of a christmas carol is the george c.
As the era of television wore on, countless shows did at least one episode thrusting a character into their own christmas carol. The best known silent adaptation of a christmas carol was the 19 version starring seymour hicks as the miserly curmudgeon. A bbc adaptation of a christmas carol will explain that ebenezer scrooge was damaged by traumatic events in his childhood that charles dickens was unable to detail due to the sensibilities of. Christmas is near, which means it is time to drink a cup of cocoa and watch some christmas movies.
A guide to christmas carol adaptations a life at the movies. A christmas carol by charles dickens 1st edition 1843. I have spent more than a generation looking for a really good book that highlights film adaptations of a christmas carol. Possibly the most widelyadapted story of all time, resulting in lots of adaptation expansion explaining events and back story the book didnt cover. Another praiseworthy version of the novel is the 1984 madefortelevision movie with george c. Of very many film adaptations of the book, this movie is the best, due largely to sims portrayal of scrooge, whose transformation from miser to benefactor is most believably played out in this film. If you are a christmas carol fanatic, like me, who reads dickens novella every year and watches seven or eight.
Since then, there have been countless stage, screen, and radio adaptations of the classic story. In addition to the countless theater productions, screen adaptations of a christmas carol have appeared almost as regularly as christmas itself. A christmas carol, lost in adaptation the dom youtube. Silly puppets, looney tunes, and a curmudgeonly bill murray await. Also known as a christmas carol in the united states. With too many different films to choose from the dom attempts a different approach to this episode of lost in adaptation. A critical examination of dickenss story and its productions on screen and television at.
1024 494 300 1167 808 729 898 825 973 536 1195 314 610 1237 416 1455 316 1441 1521 230 1344 821 265 1504 753 1071 12 4 244 188 175 1038 650 1494